brand logo
A dirty bomb story should not restart a war

A dirty bomb story should not restart a war

19 Nov 2026 | BY DR IMRAN KHALID



A reporter in The Philippines asked United States (US) President Donald Trump whether Iran was planning to detonate a dirty bomb in Washington, US, and Trump nodded. Then he spoke. “We take it very seriously because they happen to be crazy,” said Trump, before adding: “This is why they can't have a nuclear weapon, by the way, in case people had any questions.”

That second sentence gives the game away. A dirty bomb is a conventional explosive packed with radioactive material, and it needs no enriched uranium at all. Whatever Iran may or may not be planning, Trump jumped from the plot to the nuclear question within seconds, and the nuclear case is the one that he wanted to make anyway.

The plot itself stands on thin ground. The Cable News Network’s reporting cites seven unnamed officials, and they described Tehran, Iran’s planning as a way of keeping options open, not a sign of an imminent attack. One source mentioned Iranian “chatter” about materials stashed inside the US, which nobody has verified. Officials were also divided on whether Iran has the people to carry out such an operation at all. The report sets out no evidence. White House Spokesperson Lauren Bis said that “there are no credible threats to the homeland”. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin went further, calling the plot “aspirational” and adding: This isn't a new threat.”

Trump’s own Mullin calls the plot aspirational. Trump treats it as a case for war.


A war short of excuses


To see why this story landed when it did, look at the week before it. On 12 November, Trump posted: “We don't need a deal with Iran. Those days have long since passed. We've got their money.” In the same post, he told US Vice President James David Vance, his lead negotiator and the senior official most in favour of a settlement, to give his “complete and total attention” to a domestic anti-fraud campaign. On 4 November, Vance had said that the war cost the Republicans the midterms. US State Secretary Marco Antonio Rubio has called Tehran’s seven ceasefire conditions “unacceptable”, and Qatar’s mediation now sits in limbo. On Monday (16), the US Service Theodore Roosevelt arrived in the region, bringing the number of American carriers there to three. “If something doesn’t work out, I wouldn’t hesitate to act,” Trump told the broadcaster Hugh Hewitt, adding that the military was watching Pickaxe Mountain, a site linked to Iran’s nuclear programme.

Diplomacy was shelved and the carriers were in place, but the public still had no appetite for more war. In a Chicago Council survey fielded in July, 68 per cent of Americans said that the war had not been worth its costs. On 3 November, Republicans lost control of Congress. Voters have already punished this war of choice, so it cannot be restarted on the old rationale. Retaliation for a plot against Cabinet of Ministers officials in the Capital would play very differently.

Voters were tired of the war. They would not be tired of a dirty bomb.


Three grounds for suspicion


First, the weapon does not fit the war being sold. The US National Academy of Sciences says that most dirty bombs would contaminate one or two city blocks. In 2002 Senate testimony, the then Chairperson of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Richard Andrew Meserve put the likely deaths in most scenarios in the 10s. That would be a grave crime, and a problem for the Police and public-health agencies. It tells us nothing about Iran's centrifuges. A threat the size of a few city blocks is being used to justify a campaign against an entire country.

Second, Washington has walked this road before. In 2005, a Presidential Commission concluded that American intelligence on Iraq's weapons had been “dead wrong”. That intelligence was at least presented formally and defended in public. This one arrived as a leak, and the administration's own Spokesperson undercut it the same day. Twenty years after Iraq, the bar for evidence has dropped.

Third, the timing. The leak surfaced as the third carrier arrived, days after Trump declared diplomacy finished, and during the lame-duck weeks before a new Congress can open hearings. That window for a war without hearings closes in January of next year (2027).


What Tehran has done


None of this makes Iran a harmless actor. In 2024, American prosecutors charged an Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps operative over an alleged murder-for-hire plot against Trump. A memo last month (October) from the Director of National Intelligence said that Iranian plots against American personnel abroad had reached “advanced stages”. The Secret Service has moved the Treasury Secretary who runs the sanctions campaign, Scott Kenneth Homer Bessent, into housing on a military base. A billboard in Tehran reads “We’ll kill Trump”. The hostility is real.

But, the same record shows how such threats have been handled until now. Prosecutors and protective details dealt with those plots, and most of them targeted Americans abroad. An Exeter University researcher judged the odds of a dirty bomb attack in Washington “infinitesimally remote”, while warning that such an attack would hand Washington a political rationale for major military action. Iran’s Foreign Ministry Spokesperson, Esmaeil Baghaei Hamaneh said that the report was meant to “lay the media groundwork” for further aggression. Tehran would say that. The awkward fact is that Washington's own Mullin is pointing in much the same direction.


The Gulf pays first


A renewed campaign would not stay inside Iran. Tehran says that it destroyed an American early-warning radar in Bahrain last week. Iran also says at least 12 tankers have been hit in the past 12 days in a Strait that normally carries about one-fifth of the world’s oil. Trump has said that the US could destroy Iran’s energy infrastructure, bridges and factories within three days. Gulf Governments asked him to hold off. Asked whether he would have struck anyway, he replied: “Yes, I would.” Iran’s Deputy United Nations Ambassador, Gholamhossein Darzi, has promised an “immediate and decisive response” to any resumed bombing. We must expect the first bill to land in Manama (Bahrain) and Doha (Qatar), and the second at fuel pumps from Manila to Michigan.


A test the leak cannot dodge


The remedy is simple enough. Before a single sortie flies, the intelligence behind the CNN story should go in full to the House and Senate Intelligence Committees, and the administration should seek a vote under the War Powers Resolution. A majority of Americans told the Chicago Council at the start of the war that strikes on Iran needed Congress’s approval first.

If the plot is real, the evidence will hold up in a closed briefing next month (in December). If it cannot, Americans will know what the third carrier was waiting for.

The writer is a geostrategic analyst and columnist on international affairs

…………………………………………………………

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author, and do not necessarily reflect those of this publication



More News..