brand logo
Lack of regulations to monitor misleading advertisements

Lack of regulations to monitor misleading advertisements

03 Dec 2022 | By Shenal Fernando

Freedom of expression is a fundamental right guaranteed under Article 14 (1) of the Sri Lankan Constitution. However, the scope and extent of the freedom of advertising, which is essentially an extension of the freedom of expression, have not been adequately commented on and the issues arising therein remain largely unresolved. 

Freedom of advertising essentially means engaging in the act of attracting public attention towards a product or business without restraints. In order to attract consumer attention, advertisers value the freedom to be creative.

However, as in the case of all freedoms granted, the freedom of advertising is routinely abused, partly due to a lack of rules and regulations or poor implementation of existing rules. Consequently, this has resulted in calls for the regulation of this freedom in order to protect consumers as well as the imposition of boundaries in its application. 

Should we regulate advertising?

With the rise of advertising in the early 20th century in the aftermath of the industrial revolution and the introduction of radio and television, the topic of regulating advertising to protect consumers became much debated.

False or misleading advertising has been a common occurrence throughout history. Such advertising seeks to create a false or inaccurate impression of a product or service within the consumer. Therein arises the argument to regulate advertising in order to protect consumers.

However, this argument is made on the assumption that the consumer is gullible and ill-informed and that in the absence of regulation the consumer will be hoodwinked by the ‘adman’. While this may have been true in the past, the IT revolution has transformed society’s access to information and increased the consumer’s ability to make informed decisions. Therefore, the argument to regulate advertising needs to be re-examined within the present context.  

Proponents of freedom of advertising such as Ronald Coase point out the irony in the view that the state is competent enough to regulate products and services where there are believed to be market failures such as monopolies and consumer exploitation, but at the same time opposes state regulation of the ‘market of ideas,’ i.e regulate freedom speech or thought. 

This is because moral, religious, and political ideas may similarly generate adverse externalities, prey on other people’s ignorance, and cause potentially devastating damage to societies. Coase believed that this paradox with regard to state intervention was the result of the self-interest and self-esteem of intellectuals who had too much influence. “Others must be regulated, they say, but regulation should not apply to journalists, academics, clerics, or politicians.”

Similar sentiments were expressed by Dr. Wickrema Weerasooriya in his work titled ‘Do Marketers Have a Free Hand?’ wherein he endorses freedom of advertising but warns marketers about the need for self-regulation.

However, critics of advertising freedom point to the fact that the IT revolution has worsened the impacts of misleading and false advertising and that while information necessary for a consumer to make an informed decision may now be at their fingertips, the overwhelming amount of information available makes the journey to acquire such information a daunting task for most consumers. 

Furthermore, the penetrative direct-to-consumer ability gained by advertising in the aftermath of the social media revolution has allowed it to create unrealistic expectations among the public and allowed it to promote harmful products. 

Is advertising regulated in SL?

Commenting on the regulation of advertising in Sri Lanka, Attorney-at-Law N.K. Ashokbharan told The Sunday Morning Business that unlike India, Singapore, and the US, there were no specific laws or regulations or even self-regulating institutions protecting consumers from false/deceptive/unethical advertising.

Elaborating further, he stated: “The powers of the Consumer Affairs Authority (CAA) under Act No. 9 of 2003 do not expressly address false/deceptive advertising. Whilst it is preferable not to turn the state into a policing state where every aspect of trade and marketing is policed, thereby rendering doing business in Sri Lanka difficult, for the traders and marketers to enjoy such freedom, responsibility and accountability from them are also inevitably required to protect the consumer.”

Similar sentiments were expressed to The Sunday Morning Business by Sri Lanka Institute of Marketing (SLIM) President Nuwan Gamage, who stated that while the CAA had some powers to intervene, there was no explicit regulatory framework in Sri Lanka to govern the advertising industry. While communication regulations governed by the Ministry of Mass Media may impose certain restrictions on the advertising industry, its purpose isn’t the regulation of the advertising industry.

However, he pointed out that there was, to an extent, self-regulation within the local advertising industry, with major brands voluntarily self-regulating in terms of their good governance principles. “However, there is no regulation to ensure that the brand promise is delivered. There is no way to measure whether the brand promise is delivered and no way to enforce the brand promise by way of litigation like in certain other countries.”

It can be argued that the provisions of the Food Act; Intellectual Property Act; Cosmetics, Devices, and Drugs Act; Obscene Publications Ordinance; Consumer Affairs Authority Act; legislation protecting children; and the Code of Practice in Television Advertising of the Sri Lanka Rupavahini Corporation can be used to regulate misleading advertising. However, in the absence of a regulation or an authority to govern the advertising industry, such provisions are largely toothless.

Way forward

Ashokbharan proposed the implementation of a self-regulatory mechanism in Sri Lanka similar to that of the Advertising Standards Council of India, which is a voluntary self-regulatory organisation of the advertising industry established in 1985. Accordingly, he pointed out that this would be a step forward in the right direction.

“If the trade and marketing industry fails to adequately self-regulate, then it will be inevitable for the state to intervene with appropriate legislation and consequent regulations to protect consumers,” stated Ashokbharan.

SLIM President Nuwan Gamage pointed out that in early 2022, SLIM, in collaboration with the Association of Accredited Advertising Agencies (4As) and the International Advertising Association (IAA) – Sri Lanka Chapter, had launched the first volume of ‘Ethical Marketing Guideline’ at the Effie Awards 2021.

He explained that this was not a regulatory framework imposing any liabilities and instead described these marketing guidelines as a moral code of ethics for the local advertising/marketing industry. “Brands or advertisers may follow these guidelines, but there is no regulatory power behind the guidelines to enforce them.”

There is an incentive for advertisers and brands to engage in such self-regulation with regard to advertising, because in the present digitally connected world, a misleading or false advertisement can actually be fatal for businesses and brands. Given the speed of communication and the spread of news, false advertising can lead to significant public backlash and negatively affect customer trust in the brand going forward. 

 




More News..