brand logo
Constitutional crisis on the horizon as Speaker defies Oppn. appeal to revoke DDR ruling

Constitutional crisis on the horizon as Speaker defies Oppn. appeal to revoke DDR ruling

11 Aug 2023 | BY Lahiru Doloswala

In a heated parliamentary session today (11), Speaker of the House Mahinda Yapa Abeywardena stood firm in his decision to uphold the ruling on the Domestic Debt Restructuring (DDR) program, dismissing the appeal made by Opposition MPs to withdraw his previous ruling. 


The ruling, delivered on 9 August, has ignited controversy within the parliament and has been criticised for its potential implications on the delicate balance between the legislature and the judiciary. Opposition MPs voiced concerns that the Speaker's ruling, asserting that the judiciary lacks the authority to issue orders or judgments against resolutions passed by the legislature, could set a worrisome precedent. They argued that such a ruling might pave the way for a collision between the legislature and the judiciary, ultimately leading to a constitutional crisis.


Speaker Abeywardena, responding to the Opposition's plea, noted that he had thoroughly considered legal advice and pertinent matters before issuing the ruling. He clarified that he had not cited any specific court case in his ruling and, as a result, saw no grounds for retracting his decision.


National People's Power (NPP) Member of Parliament (MP) Anura Kumara Dissanayake, who initially appealed to the Speaker for the withdrawal of the ruling, raised concerns about its potential consequences. 


Dissanayake contended that the ruling could potentially hinder the judiciary from delivering judgments on court cases, thus undermining the rule of law. He urged the Speaker to reconsider to avert such a scenario and maintain the integrity of parliamentary proceedings.


Echoing these sentiments, MP G. L. Peiris warned that the Speaker's ruling might indeed lead to a constitutional crisis and disrupt the rule of law in the long run. 


Meanwhile, Chief Opposition Whip Lakshman Kiriella accused the Speaker of having an undue influence on the judiciary by issuing the ruling before the court's judgment on DDR.


In a counterargument, Leader of the House Susil Premajayamtha defended the Speaker's ruling, claiming that it merely reaffirms the supremacy of Parliament and the constitutionality of legislative resolutions. He clarified that the Speaker's intention was not to challenge the judiciary but to uphold the authority of the legislature.


Minister Nimal Siripala de Silva, contributing to the discourse, highlighted the limited avenues to challenge the Speaker's ruling. He stated only a no-confidence motion would be the appropriate mechanism for addressing such matters.


More News..