brand logo
Ali Sabry PC says: Speaker has no absolute immunity

Ali Sabry PC says: Speaker has no absolute immunity

18 Nov 2026 | BY Buddhika Samaraweera


The Speaker of Parliament cannot claim unlimited immunity from the law when even the President’s actions are subject to judicial review, President's Counsel (PC) M U M Ali Sabry told the Court of Appeal (CA) yesterday (17). 

This was in the context of lawyers for three respondents challenging preliminary objections raised on behalf of Speaker of Parliament Dr Jagath Wickramaratne in a case over the suspension of the petitioner, Parliament’s Deputy Secretary-General and Chief of Staff, attorney Chaminda Kularatne.

The writ application, CA (Writ) 109/2026, was taken up before a CA bench comprising the President of the CA, Justice Rohantha Abeysuriya PC and Justice K.P. Fernando. Kularatne claims that Dr Wickramaratne suspended him unlawfully, for a personal reason and in breach of the relevant laws and the rules of natural justice.

Ali Sabry PC, appearing for the ninth respondent, former Speaker Mahinda Yapa Abeywardana, said that Parliamentary privilege existed to protect the public interest and could not be treated as unlimited immunity covering every action taken by a politician. Ali Sabry PC, meanwhile, argued that Parliamentary privilege was not an unlimited power. Referring to the Waters Edge case, he said that privilege existed to protect the public interest and did not provide blanket immunity for every action taken by a politician. He said that if even the President’s actions could be reviewed by courts, the Speaker could not claim that his actions were beyond judicial scrutiny. Ali Sabry PC also said that it would be unfair to Kularatne if a decision taken against a person employed by Parliament could not be challenged in court simply because Parliamentary privilege was invoked. 

The Speaker has raised two main preliminary objections. The first is that decisions of the Staff Advisory Committee are protected by Parliamentary privilege and immunity and therefore cannot be challenged before a court. The second is that the word “Clerk” in the Parliament Staff Act cannot be interpreted as referring to the present Secretary-General, and that therefore, the Secretary-General does not have disciplinary powers under the Act.

Addressing the Speaker’s objection concerning the terms “Clerk” and “Secretary-General”, Ali Sabry PC referred to references to the King or Queen in older criminal laws and criminal procedure legislation. Sri Lanka no longer has a King or Queen, he noted, questioning if that meant that people could avoid liability under those laws because of the outdated terminology. In the same way, he argued, the lawful powers exercised by the present Secretary-General could not be denied by giving an overly literal interpretation to an old title in the Act. He also referred to foreign court decisions to support the argument that Parliamentary privilege did not extend beyond Parliament’s Legislative functions to cover every administrative act.

Appearing for the seventh respondent, the Assistant Secretary-General of Parliament, Kuvera de Zoysa PC said that he agreed with the submissions made on behalf of the petitioner. He said that the Act had been enacted to regulate the administration of Parliamentary staff and that Section 7 of the Act vested disciplinary powers in the Clerk, who is now the Secretary-General. He also referred to Article 65 of the Constitution, which recognises the Secretary-General’s powers in relation to Parliamentary staff.

Sanjay Rajaratnam PC, appearing for the 11th respondent, the former Leader of the House, attorney Susil Premajayantha, said that Parliament’s disciplinary procedure recognised the Secretary-General as the officer authorised to take disciplinary action against staff. Rajaratnam PC said that the second, third and fifth respondents had not produced documents establishing that the Committee was the disciplinary authority. He also referred to former Secretary-General Priyanee Wijesekera’s book on Parliamentary practice to establish that the Committee was separate from Parliament’s own committees. He pointed out that under the disciplinary procedure, a staff member dissatisfied with a disciplinary decision could appeal to the Speaker. “If the Speaker uses the disciplinary power himself, who hears the appeal?” he queried.

The Attorney General (AG) had earlier proposed a settlement in the case. However, the Speaker’s side did not agree to the proposed settlement, following which the AG withdrew from the case and no longer appears for any party.

Following yesterday’s submissions, the Court put off further consideration of the case until today (18), when the remaining submissions challenging the Speaker’s preliminary objections are expected to be heard.




More News..