brand logo

Impunity thy name is....: PTA, power & the accountability problem

25 Sep 2021

By Ambika Satkunanathan Two incidents in two prisons involving State Minister Lohan Ratwatte, who at the time was the State Minister of Prison Management and Prisoners’ Rehabilitation, were reported recently. In one incident, the State Minister was alleged to have subjected persons detained under the Prevention of Terrorism Act (PTA) to degrading treatment and threatened them with a firearm. Ratwatte, who, as the subject minister at the time, was responsible for the safety and wellbeing of those in prison, allegedly threatened the lives of the very people he was duty-bound to protect. Two weeks later, he continues to hold another ministerial portfolio. Why accountability should matter to every Sri Lankan In Sri Lanka, accountability is (mis)understood to be relevant only in relation to war-time human rights violations. The reality is that the entire country is afflicted by the lack of accountability. It is the lack of accountability that enabled successive governments to commit alleged war-related violations with impunity. It is the lack of accountability that led to State Minister Ratwatte’s egregious behaviour. It is because there is no practice of holding people to account that Ratwatte continues to hold a state ministerial portfolio. Hence, accountability, or rather the lack of it, should be of concern to every Sri Lankan citizen. Calls for accountability for the incidents in prison focus only on the State Minister, i.e. the individual, and not the system or the appointing authority, i.e. the President. Citizens should instead ask why the President appointed a man with a history of engaging in violence and intimidation as a state minister, particularly of prisons. More importantly, why hadn’t the President relieved him of the other ministerial portfolio? By allowing Ratwatte to retain his ministerial portfolio, the President was sending a message to Sri Lankans that as long as a person is part of the regime, they will be able to commit the most egregious violations and be protected from facing consequences. The many incidents reported in the media of government members of Parliament flouting the law and not being held to account was evidence of this. By breaking the law and protecting those who break the law, the Government was leading the charge against the rule of law. As a result, every citizen’s legal protections were undermined. Vulnerabilities of those detained under the PTA Reports state that of the entire population of the Anuradhapura Remand Prison, only 10 persons detained under the PTA were subject to threats and degrading treatment by the State Minister. This raises a few questions. Why did the State Minister seek only those detained under the PTA? Those held under the PTA had suffered innumerable violations, including being presumed guilty before conviction. Historically, the PTA had disproportionately affected Tamils, and after the Easter attacks, Muslims. Hence, there was an ethno-religious dimension to the implementation of the law, even though it can and had been used against dissenters as well. On 23 September 2021, the Minister of Justice requested in Parliament that the incident not be given “a political or ethnic or racial flavour…because it is not”. Reality, however, tells a different tale. For instance, a phenomenon I noted when visiting prisons was that those held under the PTA were always referred to as “LTTE prisoners” and their wards were referred to as “LTTE wards”. The morning unlock sheet listed them under the category “LTTE prisoners”. Hence, anyone who was imprisoned, regardless of whether they were convicted or not, was labelled LTTE. The Minister, referring to persons held under the PTA at the Anuradhapura Prison as “LTTE prisoners and detainees” during his speech in Parliament on 23 September, confirmed that this bias, unconscious or otherwise, was deep-rooted and structural. Such labelling also denies those held under the PTA the right to the presumption of innocence – a presumption the Minister requested we respect with regard to State Minister Ratwatte. While the Minister listed the protections the Government had taken to ensure the safety of the affected persons at the Anuradhapura Prison, there was one aspect that had not received mention – the psychological impact of the incident on the affected persons. The reported actions of the former State Minister would have had a psychological impact on the affected persons, particularly given the other violations they would have experienced as persons held under the PTA. The majority of those held under the PTA, who were interviewed for the national study of prisons undertaken by the Human Rights Commission of Sri Lanka (HRCSL), expressed they were experiencing some form of depression due to the long-standing consequences of torture they were subject to in police custody, undue delay in the progression of their cases, the lack of meaningful activities in prison to occupy their time, the lack of family contact, and the problems experienced by their families. The national study, for instance, reported that 86% of males convicted under the PTA and 76% of men remanded under the PTA stated they were suffering from feelings of depression, anxiety, and sadness to the point that it interfered with their ability to perform their daily functions. In addition, 21% of those convicted under the PTA and 19% of men remanded under the PTA stated they had attempted self-harm, while 21% of convicted men and 10% of remanded men stated they had attempted suicide while in prison. The numbers of males convicted under the PTA who stated they suffered from feelings of depression and engaged in self-harm were higher than that of those remanded under the PTA, which is explained by the fact that the average male who was convicted under the PTA had been in prison longer than the average male remanded under the PTA. The Justice Minister’s statement in Parliament, that he had made arrangements to provide maximum security to the affected persons, was welcome. When doing so, the safety of persons held under the PTA should be viewed through the prism of the continuum of violations experienced by these persons. Those held under the PTA could face reprisals by prison officers or even other prisoners, who may blame them for the public uproar following the incident, which could be viewed as “bringing disrepute to Sri Lanka”. Historically, persons held under the PTA had experienced discrimination by both other imprisoned persons as well as prison officers. As one person described it: “After I was remanded, on the same day night, we were moved to the PTA ward (maximum security, physically segregated by a wall from the rest of the prisoner population). Other inmates saw this (and realised we were for PTA cases), and they would come to the gate outside our ward and tell us, ‘we know what happened, if you ever come out of the ward, we will kill you’.” The HRCSL study reports that the degree of discrimination and violence experienced by persons held under the PTA depended upon and was shaped by the actions and inactions of the government of the day. For example, when the government of the day engaged in anti-Tamil rhetoric and implemented anti-Tamil policies, persons held under the PTA experienced more hostility and discrimination within prison. This has sometimes evolved into violence, such as the incidents described as follows: “During the hunger strike in 1997, they made us kneel. You might have seen the place when you entered prison after (the) meshed gate. After that, they started beating us. At that time, xx was in (the) Chief Jailor’s room and he was having fun watching (the) incident with one leg over his other leg.” “On 13 November 2009, there was a riot in prison. There were about 100 of us (in) the J Ward and 500 of them. They (Sinhala persons in prison) told (us) that they were going to kill us like in 1983. Around 15 of us were badly beaten, but I only had stones thrown at me.” In this context, the Government must ensure that all necessary measures, including transfers to other prisons, are undertaken immediately to ensure the safety and security of persons held under the PTA at the Anuradhapura Prison. Enabling impunity via never-ending investigations At present, there are four ongoing investigations into the incident: One by the HRCSL. Following the HRCSL’s visit to the Anuradhapura Prison, one of the commissioners, Dr. Nimal Karunasiri, was quoted in The Nation on 16 September describing the contents of the statements given by prison officers to the HRCSL. According to him, prison officers had said they had not witnessed anything untoward because they were not with the State Minister when he was with those held under the PTA. Instead, they claimed they were overseeing security arrangements for the State Minister. Based on several visits I have made to many prisons, the most important aspect of the security protocol is escorting the visitor when they are on prison premises, especially when in a high-security ward, such as the ward in which persons detained under the PTA are housed. It is, hence, unimaginable that senior prison officers would have left the side of the State Minister. The other concern about the affected persons being housed at the Anuradhapura Prison is that it could hamper the investigations, because they could be subject to pressure to withdraw or change their statements by the prison officers. The officers are implicated in the incident, as they failed to prevent the State Minister walking into prison allegedly with a firearm and thereafter, did not take action to stop the alleged degrading treatment. We do not know whether the officers immediately reported the incident to the Commissioner General of Prisons (CGP), and if so, whether the CGP took action. Did he, for instance, report it to the Minister of Justice? Did he report it to the Police? Reports of Minister Namal Rajapaksa’s visit to the Anuradhapura Prison were also concerning for numerous reasons. Firstly, it was unclear why a minister who had no authority to make decisions regarding persons held under the PTA was the first one to visit them and given assurances he had no power to fulfil. The most troubling aspect and one that is illustrative of the current regime’s strategy in dealing with the Tamil community was Rajapaksa’s advice to the persons not to be “misled by parties like the Tamil National Alliance (TNA)”. While acknowledging the numerous shortcomings of Tamil political parties, it was problematic that a powerful member of the Government, which pays scant regard to the rights of minorities, issued veiled warnings to Tamil persons about Tamil political parties. At this juncture, it appears to be aimed at incentivising them not to make an issue of the incident, since the Tamil political parties had been relentless in highlighting the incident and demanding accountability. Minister Rajapaksa had also told them they could join any political party after their release “but they should be mindful of not being used by any party”. This condescending statement was illustrative of the Government’s failure to understand that they do not have to benevolently bestow rights upon the minorities. These are rights minorities already have. The incidents demonstrate not only the dysfunctionality of our public institutions, but also the inability of our public representatives to function within the framework of the rule of law. They are examples of the Government’s disregard for the rule of law and its disdain for Sri Lankan citizens, who it assumes will tolerate its egregious actions without holding it to account. Such action will only serve to further erode the already fractured social contract between the citizen, especially those of minority and marginalised communities, and the State. Regrettably, the Government shows no interest in repairing this fractured relationship beyond making empty promises. (The writer is a human rights lawyer and former Commissioner of the Human Rights Commission of Sri Lanka [HRCSL])


More News..